What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? Editors will not send resubmitted papers to the reviewers if it seems that the authors have not made a serious attempt to address all the referees criticisms. If the authors feel that they have a strong scientific case for reconsideration (if the referees have missed the point of the paper, for example) they can appeal the decision in writing. Is it possible to rotate a window 90 degrees if it has the same length and width? Thus, in rejecting an appeal, we do not intend to imply that our initial decision was flawless, only that the arguments for reconsideration were not sufficiently convincing to exceed the deliberately high threshold for reversing a decision. Will contact my PI if it doesn't change to "decision sent to author" in the next few days. The paper is rejected because the referees have raised considerable technical objections and/or the authors claim has not been adequately established. My paper was published in a journal in 2021 october. If Nature's editors agree to reconsider a paper, the other original referee(s) will have the chance to see and comment on the report of the referee who is the subject of the complaint. Subscribe and get curated content that will give impetus to your research paper. We oversee this process to ensure that your manuscript contains everything our editors and peer reviewers need to perform a fair and thorough assessment of your work. ISSN 1546-1726 (online) Welcome to the Northern Ireland Assembly web site, which was set up to inform interested viewers of the day-to-day business and historical background of devolved Government in Northern Ireland. Is it possible to create a concave light? How long does it take to publish a paper in Journal? Either rejection or sending it out for review. Editor decision started might sound like the editor is going to bench reject your paper, but thats not necessarily the case. Answered by Editage Insights [CDATA[// > For our last submission the decision took 25 days for which the editor apologized. In all cases, authors are expected to abide by the Nature Research press and embargo policies. Icons made by various authors from www.flaticon.com, Experiential Live Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts. English Editing - Editage.com | Editage.jp | Editage.co.kr |SCI Editage.cn |publicao de artigos Editage.com.br | Editage.com.tw |Terms of UseforEnglish Editing Services. No news is good news? (You are not allowed to say "Gamma" unless you give a shape and scale parameter). But in June 2022, the journal was removed from SCI indexing, what can i do, so much of work in it with two revsions taking more than a year,what can be done, Why is a PhD essential to become a peer-reviewer. It stated 'Under consideration' until today, when it changed to 'Decision made,' and then back to 'Under consideration.' All Articles published in Nature go through at least one round of review, usually two or three, sometimes more. This decision will then be validated by the Editor-in-Chief. [CDATA[> HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. Make sure that your arguments are backed by solid evidence. At some point, they may come back to you and ask you to suggest names (additional names, if you had already given some when you originally submitted the paper). and if it is not clarified on the . The journal editor will probably make their final decision about your paper based on the changes you now make to the work, as well as the contents, its originality, and the way you write your cover letter. Locate submission instructions for a Springer journal, Submit a manuscript with your ORCID number, Submit a Nature Portfolio manuscript for Open Access publishing, Submit multimedia files to be published online with your article. All manuscripts are handled electronically throughout the consideration process. What does it mean if the status is 'under consideration' for two weeks? Special attention is paid by the editors to the readability of submitted material. Answer: The status Decision in process after Under review means that all the reviews have come in and the editor is evaluating your paper based on the reviewers comments. Most referees honour their prior agreement with Nature to deliver a report within seven days or other agreed time limit, and send their reports online. AE stands for Associate Editor. Dealing With a Negative Editorial Decision. This is known as a rescinding. For our last submission the decision took 25 days for which the editor apologized. Manuscripts should be submitted via our online manuscript submission system. I have been working in the Scientific Publishing Industry for more than 3 years now. English Editing - Editage.com | Editage.jp | Editage.co.kr |SCI Editage.cn |publicao de artigos Editage.com.br | Editage.com.tw |Terms of UseforEnglish Editing Services. Answer (1 of 4): Hi! After review, Nature Communications rejected it because of reason X. My experiences with these journals have not been this positive. How long should I wait for a response from the journal? 2022.5.11 Manuscript under submission/Manuscript received, 2022.5.12 Editor assigned/Manuscript under consideration, 6.2Manuscript under considerationNS, Decision sent to author, NZip for reviewers, 9All Reviewers Assigned109Manuscript under consideration, 2022.10.10 Manuscript under consideration/Decision sent to author/Waiting for revision, , comments, #1, #2, #3IMEC&, 2022.11.23 Manuscript under submission/Manuscript received/Editor assigned/Manuscript under consideration (), 2022.11.25 Editor Decision Started (All Reviewer Assigned), 1212All Reviewer AssignedManuscript under consideration, 2022.12.13 Manuscript under consideration/Decision sent to author/Waiting for revision, #1hhhh, #3comment. [CDATA[// > Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? [CDATA[// > Production LetPub Scientific Journal Selector (2018-2021), Nature Energy published in 2016, UNITED STATES. [2] In any state, sovereignty is assigned to the person, body, or institution that has the ultimate authority over other people in order to establish a law or change . If an author wishes to appeal against Nature's decision, the appeal must be made in writing, not by telephone, and should be confined to the scientific case for publication. So, it probably means that the associate editor (AE), who handles the manuscript through the review and publication process, had a look at your manuscript and made a decision on it, most probably for rejection. What could this mean? The author submits a manuscript and it receives a tracking number. However, the final decision may not be only that of an acceptance or a rejection. Cactus Communications. Since then we have received nearly 600 manuscripts and presubmission enquiries. The cover letter is not shared with the referees, and should be used to provide confidential information such as conflicts of interest and to declare any related work that is in press or submitted elsewhere. We understand your anxiety :-) However, the decision on manuscript acceptance depends on several factors, such as availability and responsiveness of peer reviewers and the extent of revisions recommended. March 1, 2023 - As we approach, on March 14, its 12-year anniversary, now is as good a time as any to reflect on Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") Rule 206 (4)-5 (the "Pay-to-Play Rule . availability to assess the manuscript within the requested time. var d=new Date(); yr=d.getFullYear();document.write(yr); Authors are provided the opportunity to opt out of this scheme at the completion of the peer review process, before the paper is accepted. Editors decisions are weighted according to the expertise of the referees, and not by a voting procedure. on 07 Apr, 2021, This content belongs to the Journal submission & peer review Stage. Unfortunately, as a freelancer, it comes with the job. Can I ask the editor to publish a withdrawn manuscript after acceptance? Editorial processes are described for the following stages: Atsubmission | Aftersubmission | Afteracceptance. How to write an email to the editor inquiring about the current status of my paper? Yet, little is known about how these infrastructures support, stabilize, transform or change existing editorial practices. PRX editors make every effort to arrive at a clear decision on the disposition of a manuscript within a reasonable time. The first step in making the right decision is recognizing the problem or opportunity and deciding to address it. Thank you for visiting nature.com. reach a conclusion of interest to an interdisciplinary readership. What does this mean and should I contact the editor? Not only do you need to try your luck at another journal, you also receive preciously little advice how to improve your chances. resubmitnoveltyappeal, Resubmitpoint-by-pointresponse letterresubmitresponse letterresubmitresponse letternature, Proofreadingresubmit, Proofreadinglicence to publish, NatureNatureNature, wileynature science, Nature CommunicationsNatureNature CommunicationsPeer-review, Nature Communicationstransparent peer-reviewgetNature Communicationsget50%Nature Communicaitons, sciencenature. The "Decision Started" status implies that peer review for your manuscript has been completed and the journal . It is difficult to predict the outcome of the manuscript at this stage, but you can be hopeful. If an author remains unsatisfied, he or she can write to the Editor, citing the manuscript reference number.